01 Apr Construction Law Review
Construction Law Review – April
Please refer below to our Construction Law Review, selected from AR Conolly’s Daily Bulletins covering Insurance, Banking, Construction & Government.
Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia
Bennett, Greenwood & Besanko JJ
Contract – proceedings relating to ownership and control of software used in design and manufacture of items used in construction of buildings – primary judge determined Deed of Agreement between first appellant and first respondent abandoned and termination of licence agreement between second appellant and second respondent invalid – construction of contract – doctrine of abandonment – principles in relation to copyright in computer software – ss236, 237 Australian Consumer Law – ss10(1), 13(2), 14(1), 22(1), 29(1) & (2), 31(1), 32(1) and (2), 36(1), 36(1A), 115 &135AQ(2) Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – s126Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – appeal dismissed – cross-appeal allowed to extent of variation of restraint orders and declaration to be made.
JR Consulting
Supreme Court of Victoria
Hargrave J
Insurance – non-disclosure – misrepresentation – plaintiff obtained landlord’s insurance for property he purchased – building on property damaged by fire – .property was vacant in preparation for demolition before commencing building works – plaintiff sought cost of rebuilding or repairing damaged portions of buildings – insurer refused payment on basis plaintiff failed to disclose intention to demolish, gave false answer to specific question and suffered no loss because he intended to demolish buildings – held: plaintiff breached s 21(1)Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) by not disclosing matters relevant to risk – plaintiff’s answer to question concerning demolition was false and contained misrepresentation-insurer’s liability reduced to nil by s28 – unnecessary to decide whether plaintiff suffered loss – judgment for insurer.
Bergman
Court of Appeal of New South Wales
Beazley P; Sackville & Emmett AJJA
Conveyancing – equity – appellant vendor and respondent purchaser entered contract for sale of land – agreed completion date passed – vendor issued notice to complete with time of the essence – vendor failed to provide transfer pursuant to s27 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) at settlement – vendor served notice of termination on purchaser – purchaser sought specific performance and damages for delay – primary judge held contract validly terminated for breach of essential time stipulation but ordered equitable relief in purchaser’s favour – vendor appealed against grant of equitable relief to purchaser and sought declaration contract terminated and vendor entitled to forfeit deposit – purchaser sought declaration that contract was not terminated and remittal of matter for determination of damages – “preventing principle” – held: a vendor who failed to provide transfer to purchaser in registrable form was not willing and able to complete – a vendor not willing and able to complete was not entitled to terminate for failure of purchaser to complete – vendor’s termination was invalid – appeal dismissed – cross-appeal allowed.
Barrak
Court of Appeal of Western Australia
Buss, Newnes & Murphy JJA
Negligence – appellant injured when she fell after tripping on protruding paver – appellant sued respondent for failure to maintain footpath to prevent tree roots from lifting the pavers – ss5B & 5Z Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA) – ss9.56 & 9.57Local Government Act 1995 (WA) – s5(4)(a) Occupiers’ Liability Act 1985 (WA) – primary judge dismissed claim – held: open to primary judge to find respondent did not breach duty of care – appeal dismissed.
Rankilor
Are You Underinsured? An insight into how a claim could be affected
What is underinsurance? Underinsurance is a preventable but often devastating co...
27 August, 2024Celebrating Excellence at the 2024 Strata Community CHU Awards
Celebrating Excellence at the 2024 Strata Community CHU Awards The Strata Commun...
06 August, 2024Strata Insurance Insights: Why Insurers Are Keeping An Eye On Lithium-Ion Batteries
In recent years, Australia has experienced a surge in fires linked to lithium-io...
24 July, 2024Finalists Announced for the Strata Services Business Award
Finalists Announced for the Strata Services Business Award The independent judgi...
23 July, 2024